Golden Eaglet kills Sibling, Darling catches a fish, Blue survives another day…Sunday in Bird World

7 July 2024

Good Morning Everyone,

Oh, goodness. The operative word in parts of North America is ‘hot’. It is not as hot as it has been in Winnipeg – say last summer when we reached 38 degrees C and that might still happen – but, it is ‘hot’ and humid. The garden feels like you are inside a greenhouse. ‘The Boyfriend’, Calico’s tuxedo cat friend with whom she used to visit the garden last summer, slept in the shade of the lilacs while we were planting. We voted, and he got a big tin of sardines for his supper—poor thing. I wish he would stay in the garden. There is a fantastic place for him to sleep, lots of water, and lots of food. Much to my dismay, he can catch a sparrow if he wants. Oddly, he never bothers the birds at the feeders. It was Calico that did!!!!!!!!

Saturday morning, Baby Hope and Calico rested on the tiles in the conservatory, watching a host of baby birds trying to eat seed and Virginia Creepers. One of those babies was a Brown-headed Cowbird. You might recall I mentioned that the Cowbirds had visited the garden 4-6 weeks ago. Well, they snuck at least one of their eggs into the nest of either a sparrow or a European Starling. Those parents fed that baby Cowbird while its parents were off having a holiday! It is approximately three times the size of the baby sparrows. I do hope to get some good photographs of them.

Playing with the phone!

Everyone is vying for a chance to get some cheesy dogs on Saturday evening. There are 9 Blue Jays and 6 European Starlings, a handful of Grackles and 7 Crows at the buffet. The squirrels are over in the lilacs going after peanuts, and a little woodpecker was here eating suet. Oh, they are all so happy. Their songs are beautiful and loud.

We went for a walk at the nature centre and sat on a bench overlooking one of the ponds in the shade. It was idyllic. The slight breeze was cool.

After, I did something I shouldn’t have. We returned to the greenhouse to search for Allium, more tomatoes, and another Hosta. We came home with those, along with a tray of Persian Peppers (they are super sweet) and eggplants, celery, some colourful Milkweed and daisies, and some Jalapeno pepper plants. Almost the makings for salsa! Does anyone have a favourite homemade salsa recipe they would like to share? The greenhouse is closing tomorrow and they were practically giving the plants away today. As I drove away, I wondered what they do with the plants that are left. I hope they give them to people who might not otherwise have the opportunity to enjoy some fresh flowers or veggies.

We are always looking for real-life examples to demonstrate that human behaviour has a significant impact on our raptor families. Here is Terri from FORE, who tells us how she helped protect one Osprey family that has had problems in the past with fireworks. Please read! And thanks, ‘J’, for sending this to us! Thank you, Terri, for making sure this family was safe. You are our hero.

Friends of the Redding Eagles-FORE

Every year on the 4th of July, I am always deeply concerned for the Osprey family who just happen to nest directly across the river from the Redding Freedom Festival where the fireworks display occurs. Last year, 2 of the 3 chicks bailed out of the nest sometime on the 4th of July & were never seen again. 🙁 Somehow, 1 osprey chick did survive the “night of terror” and my friend followed that one for quite a while.

My dear friend and our old mutual friend, “Ospreyman Jim”, R.I.P. have spent many hours watching this beautiful raptor family. Ospreyman Jim named this pair “Ozzie & Harriet” and over the years “Eaglewoman” & “Ospreyman” had a lot of fun joking about who was the better raptor, eagles or ospreys? Sorry Jim, but you know where I stand on that one!🤣

But, honestly I love all raptors including ospreys & all wildlife & I have deep concerns going forward for all of them. I am committed to do whatever I can do to help them & give them a voice, as are all of my Wildlife Warrior friends out there!

So, on this 4th of July, my friend & I worked with our Raptor Rescue Angel Marily Woodhouse from Defiance Canyon Raptor Rescue to come up with a plan to do what we could do to help this beloved Osprey Family.

My friend & I met down at the Osprey Nest Area at 9:30pm, which was a complete Zoo on the 4th of July! This is a very popular spot to watch the Redding firework display since it is literally right across the river from it! We had scoped out a spot ahead of time where, using my binoculars, I could keep an eye on the nest & watch to see if any of the chicks bailed out during the fireworks. Then, we found a trail that we could easily go down to the area under the nest if any of the chicks bailed. We brought all of the supplies we needed to capture them, if we could reach them, and then we planned to meet Marily so she could take them to her Raptor Rehab Center up in Manton. (My only fear was they might end up in the river where I believe last year’s 2 chicks ended up & then we wouldn’t be able to reach them.) But, we figured we needed to take a shot because there was also a chance they could land down below the nest in the blackberry bushes or in a spot where we could reach them.

Thankfully, my friend advised me ahead of time to bring ear plugs & I honestly don’t think I would’ve made it without those! I have extremely sensitive hearing along with being a very sensitive person, so this was not somewhere I really wanted to be! It was truly one of the most difficult things I’ve ever done! And I’ve had to do some really difficult things lately as you all know. 😢Those 20 minutes of horror felt like it went on forever! Watching those poor ospreys up there in the nest trying to comprehend what in the world was happening to them & to their peaceful, quiet habitat was absolutely torturous for me. 🙁 It sounded like they were being shot at with a shotgun repeatedly for 20 minutes! 

Mama Harriet stayed in the nest with the 3 chicks the whole time, but at one point when the fireworks first started, she began flapping her wings & hovered above the nest for a second before she landed back in there with her babes. I was so glad she did!

I thought for sure they were going to all bail out, because if I had been up in that nest I know I would have! There were so many extremely loud concussive blasts this year, and the last few minutes were filled with them! And it is so close to the Osprey Nest which is right across from the Redding Rodeo Grounds. 

We were so relieved when it finally ended at 10:20pm and none of the chicks had bailed out!!! I was so glad it was over & I know Harriet & her chicks were, too! 

My friend went down the next morning at 6:30am to check on the Osprey family & all 3 chicks were in the nest with their sweet Mama Harriet. He said Harriet stayed in there the whole time he was there & I’m sure it was going to take her a while before she felt safe enough to leave her babies alone after what had happened there the night before! Good ‘ole Ozzie brought in 2 fish for the kiddos while my friend was there, so that was a great sign & they need all of the hydration they can get right now with these ridiculously high temperatures we’ve had! It reached 117 degrees yesterday & expecting 119 degrees today! What wildlife can survive these temperatures?!? These 3 chicks are due to fledge around July 12th so they still have a ways to go so I’d ask that you please keep them in your thoughts this next week & hopefully they will make it!

I know part of why this is so upsetting to me is partly because I’m older & wiser now. I still remember when I was younger I really enjoyed watching firework displays with my family & friends & never even considered how it affected wildlife! But, it’s also because now I am so lucky to spend so much time observing our Redding Eagles & many other Eagles & wildlife on a daily basis. I’ve grown to love them & care for them so deeply as if they are members of my own family. So, watching this osprey family having to endure 20 minutes of pure terror felt so wrong to me? It almost made me physically sick to my stomach. 😢I’m sure It didn’t help that I’m still traumatized from what happened or our Luna & Sol 😢

Aren’t there any protections for these nesting Ospreys? I know they are protected by The Migratory Bird Act & several Federal Laws just like Bald Eagles are? According to those laws, you are not allowed to disturb an active raptor nest? So, I’m not sure how this has been allowed to happen each year? Because I can tell you, it was definitely disturbing to this Osprey Family!

So, I’m not trying to be controversial, but I simply would like to start a conversation about what can be done? Is there anything Fish & Wildlife can do? (I will be speaking to them about this & I will let you know what they say.) Would the City ever consider changing the location? I know this has been happening at this location for many years & I’m sure there are good reasons for it being there. Would the City consider using an alternative to fireworks? As many of you know, we live in a high fire danger area & this really seems to be a potential recipe for disaster? Anything we can do as a City to prevent future wildfires is a positive step in my book! I don’t see things getting better as far as our fire danger goes…

Several other Cities are beginning to use drones instead of fireworks, is that something the City of Redding & the McConnell Foundation who pays for the event would consider doing? Raptors don’t like drones, but as long as they are not flying immediately above the Osprey Nest I think they would tolerate drones since it would be happening at 10pm when it is dark & they are not active or flying around. So, that might be a good alternative to consider?

I honestly don’t want to spoil the fun for anyone! But, if we could put our heads together & try to find something that is still awesome & enjoyable for us humans to watch, but at the same time doesn’t disturb wildlife, that would be a win-win for all of us! Not to mention our own dogs & cats!

Here’s an article with more information about other Cities who are now using Drones instead of Fireworks & it looks really cool! I know change is hard for all of us humans, but maybe it is time for us to start thinking outside the box & try something new?!? We are the ones who are supposed to be taking care of the wildlife on our Planet so this would be a great start!

~Terri

If you are concerned about Blue at the Hancock Boundary Bay nest, things looked alright on Saturday. Blue had an early breakfast. Mum was in the nest during the night. It was a nice chunk of ‘something’, and I bet it is enough to keep Blue alive for another day.

Look at Blue. He looks good – I can’t tell if that is a wing or a huge crop. That shade that David Hancock designed for the eagles is really important. It is nice that someone is thinking about their welfare in times of extreme heat.

The Estonian Golden Eagle nest has lost its second chick. The oldest killed it during the past day. This has been expected since the eldest was not successful when the second chick was quite small. The parents withhold food, waiting and watching. Once the second is killed they bring in food.

The Dorset Hobbys welcomed their first hatch on Saturday! No doubt there could be more by the time you read this post.

At Cal Falcons, Sol wants back in the nest.

Mary Cheadle posted a compilation video from 2018. It was the only other year the Loch Arkaig nest did not fledge chicks. The Pine Martens took the eggs of Louis and Aila.

It was windy in Newfoundland on Saturday. Even so, Beaumont continued to provide nice fish for the family. Hope is doing better than she has in previous years feeding their babies—I just wish she would focus more on making sure that they get lots. That little one is feisty and figured out how to get around the big sib for some nice bites at one meal.

Field Farm is still doing great. The four are magnificent. What a nest! It should put a smile on all our faces when others fail.

Clark PUD is in the centre of the heat in the Pacific NW. Dad brought in a small fish for Mum and Only Bob mid-morning on Saturday. Both ate! ‘PB’ reports a large fish coming in later for the family. Way to go Dad!

The Port of Ridgefield cam keeps going offline. Let me know if you happen to catch in on and see how Only Bob is doing. Thanks!

Need a Jackie and Shadow ‘stick fix’? I sure did!

It sounds like Eclipse is wanting some prey, Annie and Archie. No one is reponding..ah.

Little Bob at Blackbush has been brow beaten during a dreary day on the nest. Sometimes it was difficult to see if it got any fish, but it was clear in this feeding that once Big was satisfied, then Middle, Little could eat. Relief.

Things look alright for Only Bob at the Minnesota Landscape Arboretum nest.

Geemeff sends us her Daily Summary for Loch Arkaig and The Woodland Trust:

Daily summary Saturday 6th July 2024

Dorcha visited the nest several times today and spent long periods fish-calling, but to no avail. Louis didn’t appear on nest cam although the off-nest reports from LizB showed he was in the area for long periods of time but chose not to respond to Dorcha. He has brought four fish to the nest for her since the chicks were removed on 1st July, perhaps he’ll arrive on the nest with one tomorrow, or possibly give it to her on her favourite perch tree. No activity at Nest One today, no sign of Garry LV0 and the only other nest visitors were a pair of Hoodies pecking around Nest Two without finding any scraps. The weather was much more settled, none of the thunder showers materialised, and tonight’s forecast is partly cloudy with light winds, and some sunshine with a few showers tomorrow. 

Night cam switches on (day cam): Nest One 23.39.42 (03.29.32); Nest Two 23.27.44 (03.33.56)

Today’s videos:

https://youtu.be/3dWj2hvSzvE N2 Dorcha arrives early, fish-calling, but gets no response 06.03.41

https://youtu.be/jE9WeBXZE4g N2 Dorcha returns at midday but still no Louis 13.22.34

https://youtu.be/fKAlAJUJQ0Y N2 Dyson & Henry Hoodie arrive but there aren’t any scraps for them 20.31.31

https://youtu.be/yCVDmwY87Ic N2 Dorcha pays a late evening visit and calls to no avail 22.14.25

Watch the Loch Arkaig Osprey livestream 24/7 and join in the conversation here:

https://www.woodlandtrust.org.uk/trees-woods-and-wildlife/osprey-cam

The trio at Mashpee NWR in Massachusetts are doing so very, very well. Fledges coming!

The heat that is hitting the Pacific Northwest nests will be moving through and ‘PB’ sent me information that shows that the Missoula nest of Iris and Finnegan will have 101 F temperatures in the coming week. This will hit other nests in Montana. Send them good wishes

.The third hatch at the Ferguson Museum Osprey nest has died of starvation. Sadly, we may see quite a few more before next weekend. This season began with great saddness at many of the eagle nests and continues with the ospreys and even the hawks as Angel and Tom did not, as far as we know, have a clutch this season.

Sandpoint had an early fish and a late one. Both small but Mum and Only Bob had some fish. Thanks, Dad.

The nest is in Sandpoint, Idaho. The weather for the coming week at Sandpoint:

This Osprey breeding season the weather is having a huge impact on nest success worldwide. The chart below is from the eggs that we are monitoring. Those numbers will change by the time that all have migrated but weather is significant.

Two beautiful fledglings at the Virginia Institute of Marine Science on their nest wishing for a fish.

Marilyn feeding her two beautiful osplets at Maryland Western Shore for Old Town Home. The third hatch died of siblicide/starvation on 31 May.

At the BUNDstiftung Goitzsche-Wildnis, the nest is really full of osplets with flapping wings! They were ringed on the 25th of June and fledgling is expected any moment!

At the Great Bay nest in Greenland, those osplets are big, appear to be healthy and well, they are just beautiful. Mum feeds, some want to feed themselves.

The Only Bob at Marder’s Osprey nest on Long Island is doing nicely. The other two eggs did not hatch. This sweet baby is 28 days old today.

‘H’ sends in her wonderful reports:

7/6 Osoyoos osprey nest:  It is quite warm in Osoyoos, and predicted to be even hotter in the next few days.  Osoyoos reached 35C/95F at 17:00.  There were only three fish brought to the nest today.  The first fish at 0841 was tiny and only provided for a 4-minute meal.  Little only ate a couple of bites.  The next fish at 1017 was large.  There was some initial beaking of Little and intimidation of Middle by Big.  Middle started to eat at 1023, and by 1028 Big moved away from Soo.  At 1030 Little had a 6-minute private feeding.  Soon, the siblings were all eating side-by-side.  Little also ate solo for another eight minutes at 1049.  The meal lasted for 50 minutes, until 1108.  The next fish was delivered 9.5 hours later.  The kids had spent all day trying to stay in the shade of ‘Mombrella’.  At 2041 Olsen delivered a medium sized headless fish.  Middle beaked Little, and Big beaked both Middle and Little, so Soo fed Big.  Middle was allowed to join in the meal at 2052.  Little grabbed a quick bite at 2056, so Big tried to beak Little, but missed and beaked Middle instead.  So, both Middle and Little were out of the feeding, and Middle beaked Little.  At 2059 Middle was back at the table and Big moved away.  Little arrived, but there was hardly any fish left.  Little ate a total of 8 bites of fish and the tail at this feeding.  The meal lasted 20 minutes.  None of this was unexpected.  We knew that Olsen was going to have a difficult time finding fish to catch in this heat.  And, we knew that the previously peaceful nest might become unsettled.  On 7/7, the temperature is predicted to reach 100 F/ 38C, sunny with light winds.

7/6 Audubon Boathouse osprey nest: Things are going well for these ospreys that live on top of a boat house.  Harbor is 22 days old, and Gray is 18 days.  Despite being four days apart in age, the siblings seem to be getting along well.  

7/6 Forsythe osprey nest:  46-day-old Larry is doing well.  Despite the heat, Oscar and Opal have been able to provide fish for their only remaining osplet out of four.  Larry was achieving some lift while wingersizing today.  All hopes are for Larry to successfully fledge, in order to salvage some joy for this nest that has been incredibly sad this season.

7/6 Captiva osprey nest:  Ding did not eat on 7/5, and had made several unsuccessful attempts to catch a fish by diving from the nest platform.  This morning, Ding started out her day by resuming her fishing attempts.  At 10:26, we saw her dive from the right perch into the water below.  She quickly exited the water, circled around and landed back on the nest with a fish!  Ding had caught a needlefish.  Congratulations, Ding!  How wonderful it was that we got to see Ding catch her first fish.  We savored every bite of that needlefish right along with Ding.  After her meal, Ding resumed her fishing, making multiple attempts.  Later in the afternoon, Edie delivered a meaty partial tilapia for Ding.  Even though her catch-to-attempts ratio will be very low at first, we are all so relieved to know that Ding may be able to provide for herself, so that she doesn’t have to rely on her parents.  We have been told not to expect a report on Darling from CROW until Monday at the earliest.

7/6 Fortis Exshaw osprey nest:  Louise, Harvie, and their 21, 23, and 25-day-old youngsters continue to do well.  Harvie is a great provider, and there has been no significant aggression among the siblings.

‘A’ reports:

The weather in southeastern Australia is due to start warming up but only to be replaced by a lot of rain. Poor Lady and Dad are incubating in this weather, and obviously, the need to keep the eggs dry is paramount. It is now 9pm and here is today’s ranger report from WBSE:

July 7: Lady incubated all night, and was then relieved by Dad shortly after 7am. All day, she was reluctant to get off the eggs when he returned to the nest, whereas he backs straight off. Both have brought in green leaves several times, though no food. Late in the afternoon, Lady was whining for food when Dad turned up, but no delivery. She spent longer today on the eggs than he did – over 7 hours. As usual, the eggs were uncovered only very briefly. At dark, Dad settled early, as did Lady – though she was hungry. The picture shows Lady, reluctant to move off the eggs.

At Orange, it is also 9pm, Xavier is currently perched on the ledge of the scrape (Diamond is perched on the microwave), which is unusual – They are each using the other’s normal sleeping place tonight for some reason. Dear Xavier. Such an adorable little falcon. He has been mating with Diamond, bringing her food gifts and generally bonding. These two still have a way to go until egg-laying time (as I mentioned, she laid her first egg on 26 August both last year and also the year before). 

Finally, at Taiaroa Head, the chicks are becoming friends again after the altercation that resulted from TFT’s attempt to take over TF chick’s nest, an advance that was not well-received. TF has reorganised his garden and resumed his throne after the small disagreement. Both chicks are well, growing fast, and starting to look like albatrosses instead of giant cotton balls. Those wingspans are looking impressive, reminding us that we are approaching the age where they will start to try feeling the sensation of wind beneath their wings. Bittersweet, like all fledges, but in this case, even more so, because it will be so very long (if at all) until we see them land back near their natal nest. It astounds me that after all those tens of thousands of kms and all that time at sea, each of them has somehow imprinted the place from which they fledge, returning there for their first forays into socialising and the task of finding a mate. It is astounding. 

Finn brought one of his huge whitefish in about 18:57 but took it away again (luckily everyone already had smallish to medium crops) and didn’t return it until after 19:43, by which stage Finn had a very large crop. Only after he had eaten for nearly an hour did the chicks get fed. This is not a habit I like. Surely, he can wait for the chicks to eat before he has to spend an hour stuffing his face. It is the one thing that really annoys me about him. Why bring it in, give it to Iris, and then wrestle it back from her almost immediately? If there was sibling aggression on this nest, that is exactly the sort of behaviour likely to trigger it. 

But fortunately, that is not happening on this nest and the chicks are well fed and well behaved enough for it not to be creating a problem. Hopefully, Finn will learn not to do this, especially when the osplets are young. He is still spending all night, every night, on the perch, guarding his family, and if the intruder landing on the nest the other day is anything to go by, he has a reason to be wary. He is doing a wonderful job, despite my nit-picking at his delivery routine. He is bringing a lot of fish to this nest and he is looking after both Iris and their chicks. You know how impressed I am by him. 

‘PB’ reports that fish have come in to Cowlitz and Steelscape ahead of today’s high heat and that all ate including Little at Cowlitz who had about 100 bites. This is wonderful.

And last, a run away yacht crashed into the Port Lincoln Osprey nest barge! Thanks to Bart M and Port Lincoln was notified immediately. So glad no eggs or chicks on that nest.

Thank you so much for being with us today. Please take care of yourself. Remember to drink lots and lots of water and to eat some watermelon – low in calories and it is 91% water! See you soon.

Thank you to the following for their notes, posts, comments, questions, videos, announcements, articles, images, and streaming cams that helped me to write my post today: ‘A, Geemeff, H, J, PB’, FORE, Eagle Club of Estonia, HWF-BBC Central, SK Hideaways, Mary Cheadle, Newfoundland Power, Field Farm, Clark PUD, Blackbush Ospreys, MN Landscape Arboretum, Geemeff and The Woodland Trust, Mashpee NWR, The Weather Network, Ferguson Museum, Sandpoint Ospreys, International Osprey Data Project, VIMS, Maryland Western Shore for Old Town Home, Goitzsche-Wildnis, Great Bay Ospreys, Marder’s, Osoyoos, Audubon Boat House, Forsythe, Window to Wildlife, Fortis Exshaw, Sea Eagle Cam, Orange Falcons, Royal Albatross Colony, Lady Hawk, Montana Osprey Project, and Port Lincoln.

6 Comments

  1. bluemarble72 says:

    Well it happened, the eldest GE eaglet in Estonia killed it’s sibling, as I worried it would. #1 has been attacking it’s sibling since they were hatchlings. Finally #2 is out of his/her pain and suffering. ): The poor baby tried so hard to survive.

    This will be the last GE nest I ever watch. I still don’t understand why there was no intervention to save #2? Very sad.

    1. The pair were so close to fledging. It made no sense to me that food was withheld. You noticed that prey returned to the nest fairly quickly. Read up on the birds/raptors that practice siblicide so you know what to expect. The second eaglet was such a survivor form the beginning. Who was to say it would not have been the one to survive in the wild. It was a loss. — The nest is in a military area of Estonia. Tensions are high and there are practices, active events all the time and it is difficult to get permissions.

  2. bluemarble72 says:

    Anyone watching this nest could see this coming a mile away. The oldest chick (probably a female) was very aggressive from the start. What bothers me the most about this situation is that no attempt was made to rescue #2 when it was obvious he/she would be killed by it’s older sibling.

    I understand how common GE Obligate and Facultative siblicide is so I’m not a fan of watching GE nests with two eaglets. I did watch Zenit several years ago but when there are two eaglets in the nest I tend to stay away. I only watched this year because there was a period of plentiful food when both chicks were being fed and seemed to be thriving, although #2 was always wary and scared of it’s older sibling. He/she was a resourceful eaglet and wanted desperately to survive. It did everything it could to have a chance to live and fledge.

    I don’t understand why an effort was not made to rescue #2 since Kotkaklubi was aware of how dire the situation on the nest was. On July 3 this was posted “We are aware of the situation and are monitoring what is happening.” “Also I do not want to say that the situation is not serious, it is! But let’s wait a few days more.”

    There have been so many deaths on nests this year, some have been rescued with a good outcome and some have been rescued with a sad outcome. But at least try. #2 could have been a beautiful GE but never got the chance to be removed from a bad situation. That’s what bothers me the most.

    1. As you know, I am an interventionist and the two were so close to fledge that this was an outright tragedy. Sadly, the Eagle Club did not say if they were refused entry to the area or if they even tried. Too many say ‘Let nature take its course’ – well, humans have destroyed nature and it is our responsibility to help. I share your grief, completely.

      1. bluemarble72 says:

        I know you believe we should intervene to help birds in trouble and I share that belief as well. As you said humans have contributed to the destruction of nature and it’s our duty to do everything we can to help birds when they struggle. The cameras are a window into their world but also a way for us to respond to birds in need. #2 was in grave need, this didn’t have to happen.

        I don’t know why this particular death hit me so hard but I think it’s what you said, they were so close to fledge and #2 tried so hard to survive but you could see he/she was growing weak from lack of food, I’ll never understand why there was no attempt at intervention since Kotkaklubi stated they were aware of the situation and how dire it was but said they wanted to wait a few more days.

        I was rooting for this baby, who suffered so much from the very beginning. Thanks for your kind words Mary Ann, I believe many people were affected by this death because it was so senseless.

        Fly high little #2, you were loved by many.

      2. It is beyond sad. It hit me very hard, too as there was no proof that the second hatch was less capable than the first.

Leave a Reply