The continuing sadness at the Dale Hollow Nest

19 March 2022

I wanted to use the word ‘madness’ in the title instead of ‘sadness’ but I do not want to be one of the sensationalizing tabloid type newspapers.

WARNING: This is not graphic in terms of the images except for two. The text information helps to understand this nest on the border of Kentucky and Tennessee better.

It is most helpful to have the data of hatch times and feeding times so that you can get a clear picture of what has happened at a nest – the good and the bad. I now have all of the fish deliveries for the Dale Hollow Nest and the precise times of the three hatches. This is extremely informative when compared with other Bald Eagle nests.

I also want to say that if you look at some of the other nest chat’s you will notice that they list the poop shot times. This is really important. I did not observe either DH15 or DH16 having any PS for a number of days. These were not continually recorded. The internal organs of the chicks, as they suffer dehydration and starvation, begin to shut down.

This nest started out somewhat promising. My observation is that the female has done an inordinate amount of hunting and fishing for prey when she would normally be on the nest brooding the chicks especially at these early days. The nest had both rain and snow.

Hatches:

  • DH14 (Big) – 25 February 2022 at 11:16
  • DH15 (Middle) – 25 February 2022 at 11:51
  • DH16 (Little Bit) – 28 February 2022 at 13:21

Prey Deliveries:

  • 26 February – R fish head at 07:51; O squirrel at 08:12; O catfish head at 09:54; and O catfish head at 13:59
  • 27 February – There was no prey delivery
  • 28 February – There was no prey delivery
  • 1 March – There was no prey delivery
  • 2 March – R fish at 05:52:57. All nestlings have a crop drop. DH14 has a ps.
  • 3 March – O fish at 16:35
  • 4 March – R fish at 08:52:08
  • 5 March – O fish with a minnow in mouth at 16:42:08
  • 6 March – O fish at 05:55; R fish at 09:20:30
  • 7 March – O fish at 12:23; O fish at 15:19:42
  • 8 March – There was no prey delivery
  • 9 March – R crow at 06:55; R fish at 15:33:12
  • 10 March – R fish at 09:13:30; O fish at 11:33:41; R fish at 14:42:13
  • 11 March – ? fish at 10:52; O fish at 16:49:35
  • 12 March – O fish at 12:43:27; R fish at 13:01:27. Snowed overnight. All chicks lined up and eating.
  • 13 March – O fish at 11:47:14; R squirrel at 15:31:48; O fish at 16:56:20
  • 14 March- There was no prey delivery
  • 15 March – R fish at 09:14:51; R fish at 12:51:32. Minnow in mouth of 12:51 fish fed to DH14
  • 16 March – R fish at 07:23:01. THIS IS THE LAST MEAL THAT DH15 AND DH16 WILL EAT AND HAVE A CROP. BIG IS ALREADY CONCERNED WITH LITTLE BIT. BOTH MIDDLE AND LITTLE EXHIBITED SNATCH AND GRAB BEHAVIOURS.
  • 17 March – R fish at 14:29:13; O fish at 18:16. DH14 is the only chick to eat save for a few bites to DH15
  • 18 March – R fish at 07:07:04; O fish at 12:09:33. DH 14 is the only chick to eat. DH16 endures two days (17 and 18 March) of brutal attacks from DH14. At 15:30 DH14 begins a reign of terror on both DH15 and DH16. Beaking and intimidating both. This lasts until 19:20. DH16 dies of injuries and starvation around 19:11. DH14 had a huge PS.
  • 19 March – O fish at 07:04:56; R fish at 07:24:17. DH14 is the only chick to eat despite there being part of the first fish and most of the second fish on the nest. DH15 attempts to get some fish by trying to self feed. DH14 continues its reign of terror. DH15 at one point appears to want to jump off nest.

The last feeding on the 16 March where DH15 and DH16 get bites.

On the 19th of March, today, two fish. DH14 ate all but the tail of the first and will not allow DH15 to eat.

A second large fish comes on the nest and DH14 again eats and proceeds at all times to stop DH15 from eating.

DH15 trying to self feed. This chick is starving. It kept beaking the mothers beak last night begging to be fed.

Adult returns and DH14 eats again. Middle gets no food. Again it will try to self feed.

Efforts to keep DH15 away from the food have involved intimidation and physical attack.

Adult goes out of way to feed DH14 more fish.

There is food on the nest but DH15 has not eaten except for a few bites late on the 18th of March.

In an article, also posted at DHEC, the Canadian biologist and eagle expert, Dale Hancock, says, “Sibling rivalry is where the bully takes all or most of the food until that bully is full, and only then does it sit back and let the next chick get fed.” He continues, “If lots of food is available then all three chicks will get fed and survive – but not always will all chicks survive. This is nature’s successful plan but not a plan that is easy to observe.”

I have not used the word bully for DH14. These chicks are/were trying to survive in very dire circumstances that began to unravel at the beginning of hatch. Whether or not the lack of prey and lack of brooding is a constant at this nest is unknown to me. This is my first year of observations. I do not recommend this nest in the future despite the fact that circumstances can change. The frenzied killing and intimidation over a period of nearly four hours straight yesterday leaves me very cold towards DH14 and yet it is only trying to survive on a nest that is unstable. Whether or not this was a lack of prey in the area, intruder threats or both, and lack of parental care remains unclear.

All of the information on the hatch times and the prey deliveries and times have come from the log of the Dale Hollow Eagle Club (DHEC).

What a fighter Little Bit was! (updated)

18 March 2022

Over the past couple of days there was a lot of focus on the word ‘survival’. ‘Survival of the Fittest’ is most often the term used. On the Dale Hollow Bald Eagle nest belong to River and Obey, there were three eaglets struggling to survive. On the 15th of March, Big Bob’s instinct that something had shifted in the amount of prey delivery or feedings kicked in. Big Bob wanted to survive. Because of her size and weight, it is easy to intimidate the younger siblings. Some leave it at that. Others switch to some beaking but, that normally stops as the chicks get older. Others get in a killing frenzy like Big did. Middle Bob’s tactic to try and not get the wrath of Big Bob in order for it to survive was to get out of the way and literally keep its head and neck down. That brings me to Little Bob or Tater Tot.

I have watched many third hatches. That is what I do – study the long term survival of the third hatches. They are remarkable if given a chance. They are creative, quick at getting food or finding dried up food in the nest and eating it. The easiest way to say it is, “They get street smart”. I look back at Tiny Tot Tumbles on the Achieva Osprey Nest in 2021. On more than five occasions, watchers thought that today was the day that Tiny Tot would die. Tiny Tot survived because its mother started bringing catfish to the nest in addition to the fish that Jack, the Dad brought in. Tiny Tot was also clever and would eat anything. It learned to run around the rim of the nest and get behind the mother feeding. It learned snatch and grab. All of those techniques to survive worked. Every one thought that Tiny Little, Blue 463, of the Foulshaw Moss Osprey nest would only last a day or two. Its two older siblings were enormous.

There is Tiny Little or Blue 463 in the image below. You will immediately recognize him. You can quickly see the size and age difference. The parents were White YW and Blue 25. I watched one day when the Mum was feeding the old siblings. They were obviously full. So she stopped feeding them. Tiny Little had not eaten. White YW flew off the nest with the fish. She waited and returned to the nest and fed Tiny Little the rest of the fish once the two big sibs had gone into food coma. Tiny Little got incredibly good at the snatch and grab and the parents made sure it ate.

Both Tiny Tot and Tiny Little lived to become the dominant birds on their respective nests. They became the ‘boss’. Tiny Tot even helped her parents fight off intruders. She took charge of the nest. So what happened this early evening on the Dale Hollow nest did not have to happen the way it did.

Little Bit or Tater Tot had an enormous will to live. It had not had any food since the morning of the 15th. My calendar and the timing shows that to be at least 79 hours. Little Bit also had a strong survival instinct and I will never forget it.

In India, the yogis slow their breathing down. To conserve its energy, Little Bit appears to have also slowed its breathing and, at the same time, understood if it stayed perfectly still (something very hard to do), it might, just might, not get the wrath of Big. It was simply incredible to watch. I marvelled at this wee babe tricking many of us – including myself – twice. I was for certain Little Bit had not survived the brutality. So, I want to say that I really admire the tremendous effort this chick made to live. I really wish it had of survived because it had a formidable spirit.

I am glad that Little Bit fooled me and made me look silly twice. I wish it had been a third time. Little Bit endured an incredible mauling by Big but the last attacks on its head killed it. Little Bit was injured so badly that it moved its leg and eye for the last time about 19:11:46. River had come to the nest without any food. Middle moved up hitting its beak on River’s bak trying to get some saliva. There was no food brought to the nest. River dug a piece of fish bone out but there was nothing for the two to eat. Big did beak Middle several times. River looked as if she was going to brood them and then she flew off. Obey came on the nest and noticed Little Bit was dead. He had no food either. So neither Big nor Middle had any food tonight. Tomorrow, Middle will have had one small meal Thursday night since Wednesday morning. Sad. Very sad.

I want to remember Little Bit the way he was on the 14th of March when all were up at the table and it had a little crop. It was such a sweet wee babe. You can see that while the oldest sibling is quite large, the difference in size compared to the Foulshaw Moss chick, is not that acute.

I am glad that Little Bit’s suffering is over. He wanted to live so much that he endured some of the worst treatment that I have ever seen in a third hatch. Of the nests that I monitor – in terms of third hatches – there have been two siblicides. The first was Tapps on the Port Lincoln Osprey nest (2021 at 18 days) and the second is our Little Bit (at 17 days).

For those who might be new at watching Bald Eagles, the Dale Hollow Nest is an anomaly in my huge binder of nests. So what am I saying? In general, a small chick like Little Bit needs to eat less food much more frequently to thrive. After 3 weeks, the feedings change – they become longer and more frequent because their crops will hold more food. There appeared to be a pattern whereby a fish would come in around 07:09 and almost 12 hours later another would appear at around 17:09. These were not huge fish. On occasion, a fish would come in after the breakfast fish but this was inconsistent. To keep nest stability, it appears that feedings need to be regular and frequent in the first few weeks. An adult needs to be on the nest to shade the young nestlings from the heat of the sun. Even Big was losing hydration this afternoon panting away. Little Bit had its fur pulled off and had bare skin showing in parts. It could not stand the heat. It was stressful on each of the three chicks. It is impossible to tell without having the chicks weigh in but one might assume that they became dehydrated. All I had to do was look at some of the other nests to see if the adult was shading the chicks. Akecheta and Thunder were, Lena at Captiva was, etc. Typically the parents will shade or be umbrellas even when their chicks have juvenile plumage. I did see River cover the eaglets when it was raining Thursday evening but I did not see her shading them in the heat of the afternoon this week. Please correct me if I am wrong.

There will be some people who will be angry with me. On the research documents that I fill in on the nests there is a category for siblicide but there is also a category for parental neglect. Those categories appear in much of the literature on the topic. Not every human child has an attentive parent. We would like that to be the case but, it is not always true. There are degrees of human parenting that range from neglect to excellent. Likewise, the quality of care of eagle parents seems to also vary. The adults are not robots who promptly feed their chicks every hour although most do when they hatch up to about two and a half to three weeks — 8 or 10 times a day. Watch the counts for feedings at the Big Bear Valley nest of Jackie and Shadow. Eating once a day will cause an eaglet to not thrive. So it would appear that it was not just Big trying to survive but also the quality of parental care on the nest or lack thereof that combined with a lack of food.

I hope that both Big and Middle Bob survive to fledge. It is hard to lose a little one or any one of the chicks on the nest. It breaks your heart. But let us hope that Middle will survive. We need to send it our most positive wishes.

Thank you so much for joining me, for all your letters and comments, and for allowing me to be fooled by Little Bit twice. Sadly, this time Little Bit has crossed over. It was a difficult day and because of that I think I also said that ‘S’ that gave me the information on Milda’s new mate was from Lithuania. My sincerest apologies. S is from Latvia. There will be more grammatical errors and some spelling issues, probably. It was a difficult day – I said that twice. Tomorrow is a new day and let us all send positive wishes to all of the nests. Take care everyone.

Do not worry. My newsletter will come later Saturday afternoon. We all just need to take a wee break. It has been traumatic.

Thank you to the Dale Hollow Eagle streaming cam where I took my screen captures.